If you need help now, call us at: (470) 225-7710

Blog

WHY IS JUNK SCIENCE GOOD ENOUGH IN CRIMINAL CASES BUT NOT CIVIL CASES?

Posted by Ben Sessions | Nov 02, 2015 | 0 Comments

I have previously written about the disparity in standards for admissibility of scientific evidence in criminal and civil cases in Georgia. I have become more active in arguing this issue, and I have just filed an application for interlocutory appeal addressing the issue. The crux of the argument is below:

WHETHER THE TRIAL COURT PROPERLY DENIED PETITIONER'S CHALLENGE TO THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF O.C.G.A. § 24-7-707.

This case involves scientific evidence in the form of observations and based upon the horizontal gaze nystagmus, test and, if this Court agrees that it is scientific evidence, the Romberg test. The Defendant raised by written motion and in oral argument before the trial court a constitutional challenge to O.C.G.A. § 24-7-707. The Defendant challenged the constitutionality of O.C.G.A. § 24-7-707 on the grounds that it violated the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution and the Georgia Constitution. There is simply no logical and rational basis for providing the defending in a criminal case with less protection against junk science than a civil defendant receives. Why does a civil defendant facing a claim for damages arising from his alleged act of driving while under the influence of alcohol receive greater protection from evidence that has not been rigorously studied or validated than a criminal defendant facing imprisonment for the same act? There is simply no rational basis for the distinction in our law.

Under the current evidentiary scheme, a person could have concurrent civil and criminal cases pending at the same time, based upon the allegedly negligent act, and receive more protection against the use of junk science in the civil case than he would in the criminal case. It simply does not make sense.

Blog Post Provided By:

The Sessions Law Firm, LLC
1447 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 530
Atlanta, Georgia 30309

Phone: (470) 225-7710

About the Author

Ben Sessions

I work to provide exceptional service, attention, and results to each of my clients. Most of clients come to me because they are in a completely overwhelming situation. They need someone that will do more than address their legal problems.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Hiring A Lawyer

Hiring a lawyer is about more than getting a great result in your case. We understand that for many of our clients, the event that led them to call us causes them tremendous stress and anxiety. We will help you understand the process and how we can help. When you hire The Sessions Law Firm for your case, you will have a lawyer that is willing to take the time to help you and committed to delivering the best results possible.

Menu