• Home
  • About
    ▼
    • About
    • Ben Sessions
    • Locations
      ▼
      • Atlanta, GA Office Location
      • Macon, GA Office Location
      • Columbus, GA Office Location
    • Areas We Serve
      ▼
      • Albany
      • Americus
      • Atlanta
      • Bartow County
      • Bibb County
      • Brookhaven
      • Centerville
      • Chatham County
      • Chattanooga
      • Clayton County
      • Cobb County
      • Columbia County
      • Columbus
      • Coweta County
      • DeKalb County
      • Doraville
      • Douglas County
      • Dublin
      • Fayette County
      • Gray
      • Griffin
      • Gwinnett County
      • Hall County
      • Hawkinsville
      • Henry County
      • Hinesville
      • Houston County
      • Jackson County
      • LaGrange
      • Lowndes County
      • Macon
      • McDonough
      • Milledgeville
      • Muscogee County
      • Newton County
      • Paulding County
      • Perry
      • Pooler
      • Richmond Hill
      • Roberta
      • Rockdale County
      • Savannah
      • Walker County
      • Walton County
      • Whitfield County
  • Practice Areas
    ▼
    • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      ▼
      • Car Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Slip-And-Fall & Premises Liability
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Elder Abuse
      • Product Failure Injury
      • Defective Product Injuries
      • Negligent Security
      • Wrong Prescriptions
      • Wrongful Death
    • DUI Defense
      ▼
      • 1st DUI Offense
      • 2nd DUI Offense
      • DUI Drug Offense
      • Child Endangerment DUI
      • License Suspension
    • Criminal Defense
      ▼
      • Drug Charge Defense
      • Sex Crime Defense
      • Domestic Violence
      • Probation Violation
      • Vehicular Homicide
    • Workers’ Comp
      ▼
      • Calculating Workers’ Comp Payments
      • Fall at Work
  • Testimonials
    ▼
    • Case Results
  • Resources
    ▼
    • Resources
    • Preparing for Our Meeting
    • Personal Injury Resources
      ▼
      • Personal Injury Blog
      • Back Injuries
      • Spinal Cord Injuries
      • Nerve Damage
      • Broken Bones
      • Brain Injury
      • Scarring
    • Car Accident Resources
      ▼
      • Distracted Driving Accident Lawyer
      • Drunk Driving Accident Lawyer
      • Following Too Closely Accident
      • Common Causes of Car Accidents
      • Do I Need a Lawyer for My Car Accident Case?
      • Car Accident Blog
      • Step-By-Step Car Accident Guide
    • DUI Defense Resources
      ▼
      • DUI Defense Blog
      • Georgia DUI Process
      • The “Walk and Turn” Test in DUI Cases
      • The Eye Test
      • Your Driver’s License After a DUI Arrest
      • License Suspension in A DUI Case
      • Ignition Interlock Permit
      • Importance of Your Driving in Your DUI Case
  • Contact Us Now
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Sessions Law Firm, LLC

FREE CONSULTATION

470.225.7710

  • Home
  • About
    • About
    • Ben Sessions
    • Locations
      • Atlanta, GA Office Location
      • Macon, GA Office Location
      • Columbus, GA Office Location
    • Areas We Serve
      • Albany
      • Americus
      • Atlanta
      • Bartow County
      • Bibb County
      • Brookhaven
      • Centerville
      • Chatham County
      • Chattanooga
      • Clayton County
      • Cobb County
      • Columbia County
      • Columbus
      • Coweta County
      • DeKalb County
      • Doraville
      • Douglas County
      • Dublin
      • Fayette County
      • Gray
      • Griffin
      • Gwinnett County
      • Hall County
      • Hawkinsville
      • Henry County
      • Hinesville
      • Houston County
      • Jackson County
      • LaGrange
      • Lowndes County
      • Macon
      • McDonough
      • Milledgeville
      • Muscogee County
      • Newton County
      • Paulding County
      • Perry
      • Pooler
      • Richmond Hill
      • Roberta
      • Rockdale County
      • Savannah
      • Walker County
      • Walton County
      • Whitfield County
  • Practice Areas
    • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Slip-And-Fall & Premises Liability
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Elder Abuse
      • Product Failure Injury
      • Defective Product Injuries
      • Negligent Security
      • Wrong Prescriptions
      • Wrongful Death
    • DUI Defense
      • 1st DUI Offense
      • 2nd DUI Offense
      • DUI Drug Offense
      • Child Endangerment DUI
      • License Suspension
    • Criminal Defense
      • Drug Charge Defense
      • Sex Crime Defense
      • Domestic Violence
      • Probation Violation
      • Vehicular Homicide
    • Workers’ Comp
      • Calculating Workers’ Comp Payments
      • Fall at Work
  • Testimonials
    • Case Results
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Preparing for Our Meeting
    • Personal Injury Resources
      • Personal Injury Blog
      • Back Injuries
      • Spinal Cord Injuries
      • Nerve Damage
      • Broken Bones
      • Brain Injury
      • Scarring
    • Car Accident Resources
      • Distracted Driving Accident Lawyer
      • Drunk Driving Accident Lawyer
      • Following Too Closely Accident
      • Common Causes of Car Accidents
      • Do I Need a Lawyer for My Car Accident Case?
      • Car Accident Blog
      • Step-By-Step Car Accident Guide
    • DUI Defense Resources
      • DUI Defense Blog
      • Georgia DUI Process
      • The “Walk and Turn” Test in DUI Cases
      • The Eye Test
      • Your Driver’s License After a DUI Arrest
      • License Suspension in A DUI Case
      • Ignition Interlock Permit
      • Importance of Your Driving in Your DUI Case
  • Contact Us Now

Consent to Search: Why Doesn’t the Jury Determine if it Existed?

By Ben Sessions on September 25th, 2015 in Criminal Defense

One of the most frustrating issues in Georgia criminal cases is what juries don’t actually know about the case and the direct implications of a conviction, and perhaps more frustrating is the submission of some issues to the jury, while others are decided solely by the trial court.

Recently, in the Georgia Supreme Court’s Williams decision, the Court presented attorneys defending DUI charges, particularly those involving blood or breath tests, with a tremendous opportunity. However, in the months that have passed, what DUI defense lawyers have continually experienced is that judges are simply unwilling to take an honest approach to the Williams decision. I have no doubt that it is hard to make decisions that, as an elected official, seem unpopular. Here’s the thing though, these decisions are not really politically unpopular. Recognizing that many DUI suspects cannot freely and voluntarily submit to testing is just right, and I believe that if we submitted the issue to juries, we would see a different result in the vast majority of cases.

SO, HOW DID THE COURTS DECIDE NOT TO SUBMIT THE “VOLUNTARINESS” OF CONSENT TO SEARCHES TO JURIES IN GEORGIA?

Below are the fundamental cases that serve as the basis for the rule in Georgia that the voluntariness of consent to searches will not be decided by the jury:

Pierce next contends that the trial court erred in refusing to give his requested jury charge that the jury was to decide whether consent to the search was given and thus whether the search was valid. This issue, however, is solely the province of the trial judge on a motion to suppress and is not a question for the jury. Rogers v. State. Thus, we have consistently upheld a trial court’s refusal to give a jury charge such as that requested by Pierce. See Hamilton v. State; Duffee v. State.6 We similarly uphold the trial court’s refusal here.

Pierce v. State, 274 Ga. App. 670, 671, 618 S.E.2d 700, 701-02 (2005).

Our Code Ann. s 27-313 appears to have been patterned after Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 41 (18 U.S.C.A.) as both have similar wording. Federal courts are unanimous in interpreting FRCP 41 that “(i)t is for the court and not the jury to decide whether evidence has been illegally seized.” Bretti v. Wainwright, 439 F.2d 1042(7) (5th Cir. 1971), U.S. cert. den. 404 U.S. 943, 92 S.Ct. 293, 30 L.Ed.2d 257; accord, Ford v. United States, 273 U.S. 593, 605, 47 S.Ct. 531, 535, 71 L.Ed. 793, supra; Burris v. United States, 192 F.2d 253(2) (5th Cir. 1951); Miller v. United States, 354 F.2d 801(1) (8th Cir. 1966). Jackson v. Denno, 378 U.S. 368, 84 S.Ct. 1774, 12 L.Ed.2d 908 cannot be invoked to determine validity of a search and seizure. Phelper v. Decker, 401 F.2d 232, 235 (5th Cir. 1968). Thus, existence and voluntariness of consent to search are questions to be decided solely by the judge and not the jury. United States v. Aldrete, 414 F.2d 238(4) (5th Cir. 1969); United States v. Watson, 459 F.2d 588(1) (8th Cir. 1972). The trial court did not err in failing to instruct the jury on consent to search.

Rogers v. State, 155 Ga. App. 685, 686, 272 S.E.2d 549, 551 (1980).

A couple of questions remain in my mind. In determining the voluntariness of statements, juries examine the totality of the circumstances to determine what weight, if any, should be given to the statements. Why doesn’t the Equal Protection Clause forbid the different treatment of defendants (or even the same defendant) challenging the weight of confessions as opposed to searches?


Blog Post Provided By:

The Sessions Law Firm, LLC

3155 Roswell Rd., Ste. 220
Atlanta, GA 30305
Phone: 470-225-7710

Primary Sidebar

Get Your Free Consultation

  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Follow Us

Atlanta Office:
3155 Roswell Road, Ste 220
Atlanta, GA 30305

Macon Office: 544 Mulberry Street, Ste 319 Macon, GA 31201
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2022 The Sessions Law Firm, LLC
Disclaimer Privacy Policy